Photo-Illustration: The Cut; Photo: Retailer
The eyes are very sensitive. This is especially true of the eye area we call the waterline – the thin, moist strip of flesh where the edge of your eyelid joins your eyeball. It’s not particularly enjoyable to touch or think about, unless eyeliner is involved. If you want a better-than-average smokey eye or just want your eyes to look bigger, it will help contour you. You can also try a tight liner – line only the top border to make your lashes look thicker. But just like your application technique, not all liners are created equal. So, before we get into the goodness of avocados, a word from the experts:
Shereene Idriss, a board-certified dermatologist and founder of Idriss Dermatology in New York City, says to use products from brands that have conducted extensive safety reviews and to make sure you’re gentle when going near your eyes with the pencil – that is, don’t poke yourself or pull too hard. More on the second point: To avoid tugging, rubbing, and constantly going back and forth on your delicate eyeliner, you should look for cream or kajal eyeliners with cream and tip formulations. Circle glides smoothly over the waterline before shaping. The more seamless the product is applied, the less irritation it causes.
A medical professional will likely ask you to avoid dabbing (or worse, rubbing or pulling) anything on your waterline – but because we’re here, Dr. Raymond Douglas, a surgeon Board-certified cosmetic and reconstructive osteosarcoma and head of orbit-disease center at Cedars Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles, has some advice. Although he doesn’t totally recommend lining your water line as it can open the door for bacteria, pathogens and other contaminants to easily transfer to the area from fingers, utensils or pencil, but he says washing your hands with a gentle antibacterial and anti-bacterial wash before touching the eye area can make applying the medication safer. He also says that finding products approved by a dermatologist or ophthalmologist is important if you choose to apply the product to water bodies.
Dr. Raymond and Dr. Idriss both emphasize the importance of not sharing eyeliner and using your product up to 12 months. “If you were a more frequent user, say every day, then I would probably limit it to six months,” says Dr. Idriss.
Now that you’ve completed this eye-safety course, here are 17 eyeliners with rich color formulas, dependable durability, and soft shapes that work.
This is the best rated water dispenser on Amazon, with almost 9,000 five-star reviews. It is praised for being smudge-free, creamy and very pigmented. If you’re looking to line your eyes with white, a trick makeup artists use to make models look more awake, this color was especially praised by enthusiastic reviewers.
These primers are great for waterline, tight liner and overall painting because they always keep their precise shape, without the need for brushing. The vitamin E and aloe-fortified formula features lush tones like amethyst and terracotta, which founder Priyanka Ganjoo has specially created with South Asian skin in mind. Dr. Idriss also loves this pad. “It’s pretty pigmented so you don’t have to constantly monitor the liner back and forth to pick up color. This is positive as it can lead to irritation, especially if you have sensitive eyes. They also confirm on their website that their eyeliner formulas have gone through multiple safety and security assessments for their intended use and are particularly safe to use on water-based eyeliners.”
If your primary purpose with your waterline lining is to add drama, intensity and appeal, this ultra-pigmented liner is designed for just that. It comes in only one color, Blackest, and that’s what it means.
Let Rihanna create a smudge-proof, long-lasting primer in shades you’ve only dreamed of. Not only do these pencils have dramatic colors and satisfying strokes, but they also come in a variety of finishes (matte! Metallic! Shimmer! Sparkle!) and 20 shades ranging from electric blue and timeless and iconic metallic gold “Because I’m Black.”
This product’s tear-resistant formula and wide, non-spiky spot will help ease any line and be able to capture your entire face in the process. If you’re always short on time and have a lot of other things to do – upper lashes, lower lashes, brows – this Kajal and its built-in highlighter can give you a full eye look in one go. .
Kohl’s is actually illegal to sell in the United States. This pencil, created by Kristen Stewart’s makeup artist Jillian Dempsey, is the next great thing. It is very pigmented, continues to not last long and can be easily smudged at the lash line to create a softer look. It is also formulated according to a “natural” formula.
If you’re interested in lining your upper lashline for an “invisible eyeliner” look, this dense eyeliner is a good place to start. It’s basically everything you do except from a gel liner, but in a more convenient pencil form and with a slightly more pointed tip so it glides over water without slipping on your lashes.
If you want your eyeballs to look like their own, you better try this double-ended eyeliner. The brightening finish instantly neutralizes any redness when applied to the waterline, so you look noticeably more awake and alert. Swipe the darker end on your upper lashes to complete the laid-back look, your eyes won’t mind wearing glasses all day. The formula feels almost silky smooth, which might explain why its creators love sleeping eye makeup so much.
If you just want to start priming your eyes without complicating things, then Sephora’s trusty waterproof primer is a good place to start. Not only does it have a convenient retractable design, but it also comes equipped with a built-in sharpener and polisher, and comes in a range of easy-to-wear colors like charcoal, chocolate, and plum. You understand.
Unlike other primers, which come in pencil form, this one is like a super pigmented eyeshadow, but drier and darker. The old-fashioned “cake” formula makes it the best smudge-proof and fade-resistant primer. To use, dip a flat eyeliner brush into the compact tube and then gently press it into the base of your lashes, using a small back and forth motion. If you do it right, you’ll be “flicking” your way across the lashes.
This gel pencil lets you get so much color in the smallest swipe that you can create a striking eye look with just one swipe. But if you want to channel your Inner Mom Makeup and play, this soft formula gives you complete freedom before you even get started. Blur a bit then stand back and marvel at what you’ve created in minutes.
If you’re ready to party, so is this newcomer from Glossier. It comes in a range of fun colors (eggplant “Rococo”; blue-gray “Patina”) with a matte finish like waterproof and water-resistant paint. Easy glide, high pigment makes this pencil well equipped for on-the-go and last-minute applications. Keep some in your wallet in case your plans change.
You may have heard of Guide Beauty through Selma Blair, who serves as the brand’s creative director and regularly provides app tips for the easily accessible beauty line. This duo includes a bottle of long-wearing cream eyeliner and a weighted wand with a precision-tipped applicator that makes contouring and liner easier for those with tremors or tremors.
If the raccoon eyes and Kardashian’s habit of wiping away tears after each yawn are taboo to your existence, consider this simple, unshakable gel primer. It glides smoothly without having to gently tug on your lid, although reviewers note that it doesn’t give a super sharp or precise line like some other linings can. However, this formula is waterproof and anti-metabolism, which greatly cuts down on routine mirror checks and under-eye panic. Even so, if you’re planning on crying out loud in confession, it’s possible to coat your liner with a good, waterproof mascara, just in case.
One of the worst parts of your eyeliner is the part where one finger is hooked to your lower eyelid patch and your other hand is fanning your eyes while you hope with your every strand that the final liner has been set. This velvety soft pencil eliminates most of that discomfort because it dries very quickly, so you don’t have to worry about transferring a bunch of eyeliner across your eyeballs.
Choose between dreamy shades like burgundy, olive, navy, etc with these highly pigmented pencils that glide seamlessly. The formula is packed with chamomile extract, vitamin E and panthenol, which is a hydrating vitamin of plant origin, so it’s made with your sensitive eye area in mind. It’s also been dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested, so you can safely apply it to your waterline. Reviewers are obsessed with consistency and ease of mixing.
This article was originally published on October 10, 2018. If you buy something through our links, New York can earn an affiliate commission.
https://www.thecut.com/article/best-eyeliner-for-waterline.html 17 Best Eyeliners for Waterline 2022